The One and Only Ivan got shafted. The adaptation of K.A. Applegate's 2012 novel of the same name was initially scheduled for a theatrical release. Then the pandemic hit and Ivan launched on Disney+. I wish I could say I'm reviewing the film in a vacuum, but I'm not. Its release on Disney+ means my opinion is different from what it would be if Ivan were a theatrical release.
The film is fine. It is an inoffensive adaptation of a children's book that ultimately traffics in some heavy themes; the story about a gorilla who learns to paint (based on a true story, natch) openly discusses animal rights and protest art. Ivan treats its target audience with respect. It never talks down to the viewer or plays them for fools. The script, however, never reaches the heights of its lofty themes. The high-pedigree voice cast plays shockingly well to the material, never entirely elevating it but never seeming above acting like gorillas, elephants and poodles.
However, one can't shake the feeling that there are better options out there, no matter the audience. The One and Only Ivan doesn't have nearly enough and adults and might be just out of reach of young children. Teenagers who want to be edgy might scoff at another talking animal movie. Although knowing teenagers these days being into a talking animal movie is being edgy.
This brings us to its release. I would feel differently if Ivan hit theaters. Options would be limited and Ivan would fill a particular niche at the theater. The inoffensive groove in which it sits wouldn't be an optimal use of the viewer's time, but not the worst one. However, its release on Disney+ means far better options are a click away. If you're really in the mood for a children's movie that talks an adult game, look elsewhere. They're not hard to find on Disney+.
Final score: 5/10